On today's episode of Hardball, Family Research Council spokesperson and board member Peter Sprigg said that he believes that Lawrence vs. Texas (the Supreme Court decision that struck down the sodomy laws) was "wrongly decided" and that "gay behavior" should be criminalized.
His comments were in the middle of a debate with Servicemembers Legal Defense Network's Aubrey Sarvis.
Freudian slips about the lgbt community are nothing new to Sprigg. Two years ago, he said that he would prefer that the United States "export" gays and lesbians.
The entire video is below and Sprigg's comments about "criminalizing gay behavior" are at the end (the exchange begins at 7:40), but I would suggest that you watch the entire thing. Sarvis totally destroys him.
And it proves the point that in a head-to-head debate with facts on hand, religious right groups can't get away with their nonsense.
Transcript (courtesy of Firedoglake.com):
MATTHEWS: What should a young woman or man, 22 years old, out of college, officer material, they want to serve their country. But they’re gay. What should they do? They want to serve their country?
SPRIGG: Well, they should serve it in some civilian capacity, and not join the military.
MATTHEWS: Why not?
SPRIGG: Because the presence of homosexuals in the military is incompatible with good order, morale, discipline and unit cohesion. That’s exactly what Congress found in 1993 and that’s what the law states!
[snip]
SPRIGG: Don’t ask don’t tell is the Clinton compromise policy which is actually incompatible with the law that was passed by Congress. There’s almost universal misunderstanding about that. I’d like to see us do away with this don’t ask don’t tell, and simply enforce the law that was passed by Congress.
[snip]
MATTHEWS: Let me ask you Peter, do you think people choose to be gay?
SPRIGG: Uh, people do not choose to have same-sex attractions, but they do choose to have homosexual conduct [...]
MATTHEWS: Do you think we should outlaw gay behavior?
SPRIGG: Well, I think certainly-
MATTHEWS: I’m just asking you, should we outlaw gay behavior?
SPRIGG: I think that the Supreme Court decision in Lawrence v. Texas, which overturned the sodomy laws in this country, was wrongly decided. I think there would be a place for criminal sanctions against homosexual behavior.
MATTHEWS: So we should outlaw gay behavior.
SPRIGG: Yes.
And lest we forget, the rest of Sprigg's comments are extremely offensive. His implication that gays and lesbians shouldn't openly serve in the military because we may subject heterosexuals to sexual harassment is akin to saying that integration should not exist because black men will force themselves on white women.
It's insane and if FRC had any personal integrity, it would make a statement distancing itself from Sprigg's statements. In light of all the attention about the Ugandan anti-gay bill, his comments about "criminalizing gay behavior" are just ugly. Of course even if there were no Ugandan anti-gay bill, Sprigg's comments should still be viewed as uncalled for.
But I doubt that FRC will say or do anything distancing itself from Sprigg. His comments are totally on point with religious right dogma, not only about gays in the military but also other facets of our lives.
Religious right groups don't see us as people and they have been exploiting the fears and ignorance of people of faith in order to get others to share their view of the lgbt community.
The only reason why Sprigg got caught today is because he couldn't muster up enough shiftiness.
We need to spread this clip and remind everyone what Sprigg said. Whether he realizes it or not, he is the true face of religious right groups.
Behind their phony veneer of "traditional morality" and "loving the sinner but hating the scene" is a corrupt working of lies, distortions and yes, hate.
Analyzing and refuting the inaccuracies lodged against the lgbt community by religious conservative organizations. Lies in the name of God are still lies.
Tuesday, February 02, 2010
Does FRC's Peter Sprigg support 'criminal sanctions' against the lgbt community?
UPDATE - It's been confirmed.
Did Peter Sprigg, one of the spokespeople of the Family Research Council make a huge verbal boo-boo on a today's episode of Hardball with Chris Matthews.
Reports are coming in that he actually admitted that he supports "criminal sanctions" against the lgbt community.
If this story is true, it's not the first time Sprigg has made a "Freudian slip" in regards to his feelings about the lgbt community.
Two years ago, he said that he would prefer that the United States "export" gays and lesbians:
I am waiting on video confirmation which will hopefully come later tonight. Stay tuned.
Did Peter Sprigg, one of the spokespeople of the Family Research Council make a huge verbal boo-boo on a today's episode of Hardball with Chris Matthews.
Reports are coming in that he actually admitted that he supports "criminal sanctions" against the lgbt community.
If this story is true, it's not the first time Sprigg has made a "Freudian slip" in regards to his feelings about the lgbt community.
Two years ago, he said that he would prefer that the United States "export" gays and lesbians:
I am waiting on video confirmation which will hopefully come later tonight. Stay tuned.
Lee Daniels - first gay black man to receive Best Director Oscar nomination and other Tuesday midday news briefs
Lee Daniels ‘Stoked’ Over Oscar Love - Congratulations to Lee Daniels, the first gay black man to receive an Oscar for Best Director. Take that, DONNIE MCCLURKIN!! Editor's note - while the preceeding article does not talk about Daniels's orientation, this one does.
Live: 'Don't ask', you shall receive anyway (12PM EST) - For those who want to see the hearing.
A harassment-free school opens in L.A. - Regardless of what they say, schools like this are needed.
This Vanderbilt Muslim Chaplain Says He Supports Executing Gays. Why Is the University Keeping Him? - Talk about your hot messes.
Religious Right Sues Over Hate Crimes Law - Unbelievable. Or maybe not. Like the post says, what took the right so long. LOL
Maggie Gallagher commits 'sin of omission' to make case against marriage equality - You saw this piece yesterday but check out the Huffington Post version and also pay attention to the comments section. There is a young man who claims to be a gay man of color and (conveniently enough), he is trying to hijack the conversation and talk about "racism in the lgbt community.)
Live: 'Don't ask', you shall receive anyway (12PM EST) - For those who want to see the hearing.
A harassment-free school opens in L.A. - Regardless of what they say, schools like this are needed.
This Vanderbilt Muslim Chaplain Says He Supports Executing Gays. Why Is the University Keeping Him? - Talk about your hot messes.
Religious Right Sues Over Hate Crimes Law - Unbelievable. Or maybe not. Like the post says, what took the right so long. LOL
Maggie Gallagher commits 'sin of omission' to make case against marriage equality - You saw this piece yesterday but check out the Huffington Post version and also pay attention to the comments section. There is a young man who claims to be a gay man of color and (conveniently enough), he is trying to hijack the conversation and talk about "racism in the lgbt community.)
Peter LaBarbera mad at Fox News over gays in the military
Will wonders ever cease?
Our favorite anti-lgbt spokesperson, Porno Petey (I mean Peter LaBarbera) is mad at Fox News over a recent episode of the O'Reilly Factor where guests said that it's time to repeal Don't Ask, Don't Tell and allow gays to serve openly in the military:
I don't know what's funnier - the claim that Fox News is trying to "attract liberal viewers," (I especially love how the network "attracts liberals" with its continued ugly attacks on our president.) or the fact that LaBarbera calls allowing gays to serve in the military a "social experiment."
LaBarbera's pathetic screed is laughable, but that phrase "social experiment" stays with me because I've heard it used before - it's when folks like LaBarbera are talking about same-sex couples raising children.
In both cases (gays serving in the military, same-sex couples raising children), the religious right willfully ignores the fact that both concepts have existed for a long time. But yet these so-called defenders of morality feel the need to not only speak against them (and create ridiculous and distorted reasonings as to their position) but also deny lgbts our basic humanity.
To them, when gays and lesbians want to openly defend our country, we are doing it for selfish reasons and to allow us to do it is a "social experiment."
When gays and lesbians want to adhere to the natural urge to have, raise, and nurture the next generation, to allow us to do so is a "social experiment."
And why do the religious right believe this? Because to them, lgbts aren't real people; only cogs in some ignorant fantasy they have about "values" and "traditional morality."
Our favorite anti-lgbt spokesperson, Porno Petey (I mean Peter LaBarbera) is mad at Fox News over a recent episode of the O'Reilly Factor where guests said that it's time to repeal Don't Ask, Don't Tell and allow gays to serve openly in the military:
. . . on Thursday, January 28th, FOX business anchor Cheryl Casone (who stepped in for Carlson) and FOX News analyst Margaret Hoover both agreed America was ready to have homosexuals openly serve in defense of our nation [Transcript available HERE]. It was a shocker for me to hear this on FOX News–the “fair and balanced” network. Even O’Reilly fed into the liberal line which suggested it was time for this social experiment to take place. It has become all too evident the network seems to be leaning to the left, in order to appease and attract more liberal viewers. FOX would not want to offend this new demographic which has helped the FOX News Channel’s ratings go through the roof.
Mr. O’Reilly, the purpose of the United States Armed Forces is to defend America. It is not a place for social experiments or political correctness. Indeed, the Constitution does not apply in many cases to the U.S. military and FOX News should not be advocating Barack Obama’s far-left policies.
I don't know what's funnier - the claim that Fox News is trying to "attract liberal viewers," (I especially love how the network "attracts liberals" with its continued ugly attacks on our president.) or the fact that LaBarbera calls allowing gays to serve in the military a "social experiment."
LaBarbera's pathetic screed is laughable, but that phrase "social experiment" stays with me because I've heard it used before - it's when folks like LaBarbera are talking about same-sex couples raising children.
In both cases (gays serving in the military, same-sex couples raising children), the religious right willfully ignores the fact that both concepts have existed for a long time. But yet these so-called defenders of morality feel the need to not only speak against them (and create ridiculous and distorted reasonings as to their position) but also deny lgbts our basic humanity.
To them, when gays and lesbians want to openly defend our country, we are doing it for selfish reasons and to allow us to do it is a "social experiment."
When gays and lesbians want to adhere to the natural urge to have, raise, and nurture the next generation, to allow us to do so is a "social experiment."
And why do the religious right believe this? Because to them, lgbts aren't real people; only cogs in some ignorant fantasy they have about "values" and "traditional morality."
Monday, February 01, 2010
Liberty Counsel attacking lgbt parenting again but won't comment on Jenkins/Miller case
One would think that the Liberty Counsel's exploitative behavior in the Janet Jenkins/Lisa Miller custody case would induce a degree of shame in the organization. And one would think that this shame would prevent the Liberty Counsel from butting into another case regarding lgbt parenting.
Think again.
In a huge show of audacity, Liberty Counsel head Mat Staver has the unmitigated gall to comment on a recent case in Florida where a judge awarded the custody of a child to a lesbian couple:
For those of us familiar with religious right terminology and code words, phrases like "renegade judicial activism" means a judge who doesn't prescribe to their narrow-minded and inaccurate view of the law and the concept of "family."
And just like I pointed out in an earlier post regarding NOM head Maggie Gallagher, Staver is another religious right talking head who distorts research to claim that heterosexual households are better than same-sex households when it comes to the raising of children.
But Staver's other comments should give everyone pause for alarm:
Seems to me that Staver is encouraging folks not to follow the judge's ruling. One has to wonder if Staver and the Liberty Counsel also advised Miller to ignore the court when it said that she should allow Jenkins visitation with the two's daughter, Isabella.
We don't know because ever since Miller kidnapped Isabella, the Liberty Counsel hasn't commented on its conduct during the case.
But we do know that the Liberty Counsel dragged the case out, no doubt filling Miller's head with impossible expectations which led her to kidnap Isabella when those expectations didn't come to fruition.
To this day, no one knows where Miller and Isabella are.
It's too bad that the Liberty Counsel doesn't seem to know the location of either its values and integrity.
On second thought, I take that back.
I'm sure the Liberty Counsel's values and integrity are probably in a jar somewhere in the deepest darkest area of the organization's headquarters where they can bother no one, especially Staver and the rest of his Liberty Counsel colleagues.
Think again.
In a huge show of audacity, Liberty Counsel head Mat Staver has the unmitigated gall to comment on a recent case in Florida where a judge awarded the custody of a child to a lesbian couple:
According to Mat Staver of Florida-based Liberty Counsel, the action is one of judicial activism; and the role of a judge, he argues, is not that of writing laws but of interpreting them. The attorney makes note of a 1977 Florida law that bans adoption by homosexual men and women.
"This law has a lot of good commonsense reasons [behind it]," he comments. "Not only the fact that children do best when they are raised in a home with a mother and a father, but certainly sociological research bears that out as well."
. . . "This is renegade judicial activism that ought to be stopped because it weakens the judiciary, it weakens the rule of law, and it undermines the trust of the people in justice and in law," contends Staver. "Once that begins to take place, [it] unravels the entire system."
For those of us familiar with religious right terminology and code words, phrases like "renegade judicial activism" means a judge who doesn't prescribe to their narrow-minded and inaccurate view of the law and the concept of "family."
And just like I pointed out in an earlier post regarding NOM head Maggie Gallagher, Staver is another religious right talking head who distorts research to claim that heterosexual households are better than same-sex households when it comes to the raising of children.
But Staver's other comments should give everyone pause for alarm:
Staver says the Florida judge decided on her own to grant a same-gender adoption when she wrote an opinion that has no basis in law -- and her ruling, he adds, should not be respected as though it does.
Seems to me that Staver is encouraging folks not to follow the judge's ruling. One has to wonder if Staver and the Liberty Counsel also advised Miller to ignore the court when it said that she should allow Jenkins visitation with the two's daughter, Isabella.
We don't know because ever since Miller kidnapped Isabella, the Liberty Counsel hasn't commented on its conduct during the case.
But we do know that the Liberty Counsel dragged the case out, no doubt filling Miller's head with impossible expectations which led her to kidnap Isabella when those expectations didn't come to fruition.
To this day, no one knows where Miller and Isabella are.
It's too bad that the Liberty Counsel doesn't seem to know the location of either its values and integrity.
On second thought, I take that back.
I'm sure the Liberty Counsel's values and integrity are probably in a jar somewhere in the deepest darkest area of the organization's headquarters where they can bother no one, especially Staver and the rest of his Liberty Counsel colleagues.
AFA radio host supports forced reparative therapy and other Monday midday news briefs
AFA Radio Calls for Criminalizing LGBT People - You read this right. It's not a mistake but a bit of brazen nastiness.
The Pray In Jesus Name Project: 'defending our troops against open homosexual aggression' - Hot mess and a half. Apparently repealing DADT would allow lgbt hands to "roam."
Facebook Suppresses Key Group Opposing Genocide in Uganda - Facebook is tripping.
Conservative Action Project: A New Name For the Same Old Right-Wing Agenda - Not another one of those groups!
Stephen Baldwin Praises 'Ex-Gays', Condemns Gay Marriage - Stephen Baldwin was more relevant when he would show his bare ass in bad movies.
The Pray In Jesus Name Project: 'defending our troops against open homosexual aggression' - Hot mess and a half. Apparently repealing DADT would allow lgbt hands to "roam."
Facebook Suppresses Key Group Opposing Genocide in Uganda - Facebook is tripping.
Conservative Action Project: A New Name For the Same Old Right-Wing Agenda - Not another one of those groups!
Stephen Baldwin Praises 'Ex-Gays', Condemns Gay Marriage - Stephen Baldwin was more relevant when he would show his bare ass in bad movies.
Maggie Gallagher commits 'sin of omission' to make case against marriage equality
Maggie Gallagher of the National Organization for Marriage seems to always be the first to complain that her organization's zeal to stop same-sex marriage is mislabeled and she is unfairly targeted as a "bigot" or a "liar."
However, how she distorts a recent study of abused children does make the case that Gallagher and NOM tends to play loose with facts.
The study reported findings from the Fourth National Incidence Study of Child Abuse and Neglect (NIS–4), which was conducted by Westat, Inc., with the assistance of its subcontractor Walter R. McDonald and Associates, Inc. (WRMA).
Gallagher, however, uses the study to attack the concept of same sex parenting and gay marriage.
In a recent piece on the National Organization for Marriage blog, she cited it in an effort to criticize the ongoing Proposition 8 trial and the lawyers speaking against the Proposition 8 - Ted Olson and David Boise :
Here is the thing that Gallagher is intentionally overlooking - the study NEVER LOOKED specifically at same-sex households. Same sex households wasn't even a category.
Gallagher even admits this when talking about the study:
Through her distorted usage of the child abuse study, Gallagher is exploiting a common religious right talking point which goes like this: "same-sex marriage/same-sex parenting is not a good idea because studies show that the best place to raise a child is in a home with a mother and a father."
However when the religious right groups and talking heads (such as Gallagher) make this point, they always seem to commit an egregious "sin of omission" by not revealing that:
Too bad chutzpah in this case isn't the same as accuracy or respect for truth.
However, how she distorts a recent study of abused children does make the case that Gallagher and NOM tends to play loose with facts.
The study reported findings from the Fourth National Incidence Study of Child Abuse and Neglect (NIS–4), which was conducted by Westat, Inc., with the assistance of its subcontractor Walter R. McDonald and Associates, Inc. (WRMA).
Gallagher, however, uses the study to attack the concept of same sex parenting and gay marriage.
In a recent piece on the National Organization for Marriage blog, she cited it in an effort to criticize the ongoing Proposition 8 trial and the lawyers speaking against the Proposition 8 - Ted Olson and David Boise :
Here’s my question for Ted and David as they strive to prove that Science Says same-sex unions are just like opposite-sex ones, when it comes to children.
Perhaps you are right. Perhaps alone of all the family structures science has ever studied, children living with same-sex couples do just as well as children in intact married families. (Perhaps that is true even though your own expert witness admits there is no research on gay male families and child outcomes, and there is no nationally representative study that follows children raised from birth to adulthood by same-sex outcomes and compares how they do to children in other family forms ).
Perhaps.
But does this study, which is one of hundreds with similar results favoring the natural family give Ted Olson and David Boies pause late at night as they assert the scientific irrationality of respect for the natural family at all I wonder? Ted and David, I’m wondering: not even a little bit?
Here is the thing that Gallagher is intentionally overlooking - the study NEVER LOOKED specifically at same-sex households. Same sex households wasn't even a category.
Gallagher even admits this when talking about the study:
All the other family structures studied (which does not include same-sex parent families probably because these are such a small part of the population), but does include solo parents, other married parents (remarried primarily), single parents living with a partner, cohabiting parents, and no parents.
Through her distorted usage of the child abuse study, Gallagher is exploiting a common religious right talking point which goes like this: "same-sex marriage/same-sex parenting is not a good idea because studies show that the best place to raise a child is in a home with a mother and a father."
However when the religious right groups and talking heads (such as Gallagher) make this point, they always seem to commit an egregious "sin of omission" by not revealing that:
- usually these studies are talking about children in the homes of their biological parents,
- and none of these studies ever factor in same-sex households.
Too bad chutzpah in this case isn't the same as accuracy or respect for truth.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
