 |
| Matt Barber |
Religious right and conservative groups have launched two distortions against the lgbt community this morning.
One has to do with the false claim of the supposed dangers of homosexuality while the other will most likely be a new talking point against the Obama Administration in the upcoming Supreme Court Prop 8 battle.
Let's look at both distortions:
1. The false dangers of homosexuality
The
AFA's Instant Analysis published the following piece this morning:
Earlier research reinforced: Homosexuality is unhealthy lifestyle
A new study comparing same-sex couples to married heterosexuals shows that the former are less healthy than the latter.
Matt Barber, vice president of Liberty Counsel Action, tells American Family News the latest numbers were published in the Journal of Health and Social Behavior. It found that same-sex cohabiting men were 61 percent more likely to report "poor or fair health" than an equitable number of men reporting from heterosexual marriages. Likewise, same-sex cohabiting women were 46 percent more likely to report the same when compared to heterosexual married women.
. . . "We have known this for a long time," Barber notes. "There have been a number of studies indicating, for instance, that there are increased rates of domestic violence, drug and alcohol abuse within the homosexual community, and this is just in keeping with what the International Journal of Epidemiology found in 1997, a Canadian study."
In that study, homosexual men were shown to have a lifespan 8-20 years shorter than those who do not engage in that lifestyle. But Dr. Hui Liu of Michigan State University, the professor who led the new study, claims the fact that homosexuals cannot marry, as well as the burden of stress and discrimination, are to blame for the results. Barber does not agree.
Barber and AFA are incredibly brazen here. The
study in question does not even say that homosexuality is an "unhealthy lifestyle." Rather, it makes the argument that the denial of the right to marry is keeping the gay community from having better health.
And what's even more brazen? Barber
admits that this is the study's conclusion but says he disagrees with it without offering any proof that the conclusion is in error.
In other words, Barber cherry-picks a portion of the study which suits his views while dismissing the rest of the study which contradicts his views. And he does so openly and without shame.
Even the 1997 study Barber alludes to is a distortion. In 2001, the researchers of that study
complained that religious right spokespeople such as Barber were distorting their work. They never said that homosexuality was a "dangerous lifestyle." They were saying that there needed to be better ways to combat HIV.
2. Obama Administration says mothers are not important
According to the conservative
CNS News, the Obama Administration's recent brief to the Supreme Court supporting marriage equality bashes mothers:
The Obama Justice Department is arguing in the United States Supreme Court that children do not need mothers.
The Justice Department’s argument on the superfluity of motherhood is presented in a brief the Obama administration filed in the case of Hollingsworth v. Perry, which challenges the constitutionality of Proposition 8, the California ballot initiative that amended California’s Constitution to say that marriage involves only one man and one woman.
The article then proceeds to attack the Obama Administration and the American Psychological Association to reinforce its claim that somehow mothers in general are being attacked.
Of course this is a lie. Nowhere in its brief did the Obama Administration say that mothers are not important. What the brief, using information from the APA, did was to contradict the claim made by opponents to marriage equality that
only a mother and a father in a home can properly raise children.
The brief merely points out that same-sex households are also able to raise properly raise children.
But the meme that the Obama Administration is "bashing mothers" will most likely be a religious right talking point. The meme is already making its way via several
webpages including that of the
Family Research Council and the
National Organization for Marriage.
How soon will it be before Matt Drudge and Fox News starts repeating the meme?
The lgbt community should get angry at these two blatant attempts to distort their lives. But they should also keep in mind that these lies betray a certain desperation on the part of religious and conservative groups.
Because both lies are not only brazen but careless and easy to refute, thus reinforcing the fact that when one gets desperate, one starts to make mistakes.
