Editor's note - in lieu of the recent situation in which a baker has refused to make a birthday cake for a married lesbian couple due to her "religious beliefs," I am reposting this 2011 piece I wrote on "religious liberty."
I think we are in the stage I predicted. The anti-lgbt industry slowly but steadily made "religious liberty" a repeated talking point. Now they are prepared to take argument as far as it can go:
Those who are my friends know that I am a serious fan of the 1970s detective drama
Columbo.
The thing I really loved about this show was the fact of how the
character of police detective Columbo never considered a murder case
completely simple. He never bought into the idea of an "open-and-shut"
case if he had a nagging feeling, no matter how insignificant it was.
That nagging feeling is what I get when I hear about marriage clerks,
hotel owners, Catholic adoption agencies, and recently - cake bakers who
refuse to serve gay couples. No doubt you have heard about them and
will probably hear a lot more as religious right groups trying to hinder
marriage equality will canonize these folks as "saints and martyrs"
besieged by so-called radical gay activists supposedly trying to force
them choose between their livelihood and religious freedom.
In fact they have a term for this sort of thing. They call it "religious liberty."
There is a certain simplicity to these cases which garners them a degree
of support. Some of these folks (excluding Catholic charities who have
no right to taxpayer money to discriminate and marriage clerks who
should put the needs of constituents over their own desires) seems to
have a right to serve whomever they wish. And one could even make the
case that they are in fact forced to choose between their livelihoods
and their "religious liberty."
But then there goes that nagging feeling again. These cases aren't as
simple as they are made out. What about the rights of couples refused
service? No matter how you attempt to soften the blow, the idea that
someone will not serve you because of how they inaccurately view you
still hurts. It's dehumanizing, it's cruel, and it's embarrassing.
In a recent situation in Iowa, a cake baker scheduled an appointment
with a lesbian couple who desired her services only to use that time to
not only tell them no, but also to criticize their sexual orientation.
Then that same cake baker made several news appearances to decry about how
she was victim, backed by several religious right groups spinning the same talking points.